Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.By now, most people should have seen the episodes here discussed, but just in case avoid the question if you fear spoilers.
This would make Flurry Heart the first natural alicorn in the series. When Equestria was first founded, its flag already featured the two sisters (see season 2 ep 11 - Hearths Warming Eve) so even by disregarding the Journal of the Two Sisters (which canon status isnt really agreed upon by everyone) we have an in-show reference to alicorns existence before Equestria. The problem is that basically all the question is centered on that spoiler so I would probably end up marking all the text. And I guess what youre probably referring to is the whole the first time an alicorn has been born in Equestria. Yes. Theyre from a race of alicorns that were not from Equestria because Equestria did not exist. Flurry Hearts birth in S6E12 The Crystalling was surprising to Celestia and Luna not because theyd never heard of an alicorn being born before, but because theyd never heard of an alicorn being born before in Equestria. So these chicks Celestia and Luna who have been alive for a long time havent seen it. As of season 6 however, this has not yet happened, and thus Journal of the Two Sisters is still considered canon (along with all that implies about the origins of Celestia and Luna). And, just for completeness, heres Amy saying basically the same thing on Twitter. Amy was explicitly addressing the question of whether or not Journal of the Two Sisters is canon with that quote, as a response to exactly that scene you named in the season 6 premiere. I guess I should include a bit more context to make that clear. I thought Id made that clear in my answer, but upon rereading it I realize that wasnt clear at all. Fixed now. My point was that as you also stated Amy actually left the show staff. I am wondering if so far any of the current staff members (or at least the ones that were still in the staff when the episode aired) ever commented or wrote any post that confirms that they are going to change Lauren original vision about alicorns and the two sisters. Anyway, will probably accept this for now if nothing more precise comes in. To my knowledge, no current staff at Hasbro have provided any additional information about that scene, otherwise I would have mentioned that. Rebecca Shoichet, a current staff member at Hasbro who plays Twilight Sparkle and Sunset Shimmers singing voices, was also present on the panel when Amy made these comments and she didnt object, but thats obviously not proof of anything. Luna and Celstia confirm that this has never been heard of before assuming that they were born somewhat royal but were unicorns or Pegasi. Wonder if you can only become an alicorn if you are currently a unicorn. I think that Celestia and Luna were not born alicorns, but I may be wrong. Provide details and share your research But avoid Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
Details
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |